Do this trade?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

Since my last post got kind of confusing I am reposting the new offer that I am trying to decide about. The league is an AL ONLY league, 10 teams, 23 man rosters, 5x5 roto style, 7 keepers with 3 year contracts.

I have been offered:

Andy Pettitte
Rick Porcello
Jeff Niemann
Xavier Nady

for my:

Brad Ziegler
Andy Sonnanstine
Scot Shields

I am in 4th place overall and dominating the saves category since I have 4 closers right now. I need some more starters who can get me some ks and wins since I am in last place in these cats. Is this deal worth it for me?

My Team:

C-Morales
C-Zaun
1B-MCab
2B-J. Lopez
SS-M. Izturis
3B-Bautista
MI-Getz
CI-Konerko
OF-Wells
OF-Hunter
OF-Montanez
OF-Morales
OF-Kubel
DH-Thome

P-Cahill
P-Sonnanstine
P-McCarthy
P-J. Shields
P-Francisco
P-Ziegler
P-Morrow
P-Downs
P-Shields

DL-ARod
DL-Johjima
DL-Freel
DL-S. Lewis
DL-Bonderman

Minors-Wieters, Poreda

Hist Team:

C-Barajas
C-Laird
1B-Pena
2B-Kendrick
SS-A. Cabrerra
3B-Youk
MI-Lillibridge
CI-Jacobs
OF-Melky
OF-Cruz
OF-J. Rivera
OF-Magglio
OF-Rios
DH-E. Patterson

P-Pettitte
P-Porcello
P-Niemann
P-Bedard
P-Casilla
P-Cruz
P-Saunders
P-Weaver
P-Garza

DL-Ryan
DL-Ellis
DL-Nady

Minors-Perez

[angels7777]

I would ask for more myself... you are getting Pettite and a bunch of garbage - aim higher

[TheGuru]

thanks for the help

take it. If Sonnanstine continues to pitch poorly, he will be replace by Price and Shields is not looking too good

[red wing stud]

I would do it cuz I like Pettite this year and I love Porcello for the future (he could even surprise this year)

thanks for the help with mine

[yanks0826]

I would do this deal...


Help me please?

viewtopic.php?t=382288

[b3asty]

I would ask for more myself... you are getting Pettite and a bunch of garbage - aim higher

I totally agree. That looks like a sugar coated turd of trade you'll be receiving in return.

[lyons595]

I would do it...Pettitte for now and Porcello for the future.

Thanks.

[PeteDog13]

I'm taking the deal. Porcello is the real deal. Pettite gets you through this year.

[interchange]

I would ask for more myself... you are getting Pettite and a bunch of garbage - aim higher

I totally agree. That looks like a sugar coated turd of trade you'll be receiving in return.

Yeah but it's not giving up that much either. This trade has more potential so I'd do it.

[krunchyfrogg]

It's not a terrible deal, but with 4 closers in an AL only format, I'd think you have the cornerstone in that area. You can demand a lot more for your closers.

Thanks for helping with mine!