Should I accept this trade??

[JohnnnyD]

Hey guys, i was offered Ryan Zimmerman for M. DeRosa and M. Scutaro. Do you think I should accept or do you think he is asking too much since Scutaro is worth something right now? I think it makes since because Scutaro isn't going to stay hot the whole season and DeRosa wont have a season like his last, but mainly I think I need an upgrade at 3B. Should I throw fukudome in there instead of one of them? Any ideas would help.

Take a look at my team its a regular 12 team yahoo roto leage non-keeper. Thanks in advance

C-Geovany Soto
1B-Derrek Lee
2B-Dustin Pedroia
3B-Melvin Mora
SS-Alexei Ramírez
OF-Kosuke Fukudome
OF-Jay Bruce
OF-Matt Holliday
Util-Marco Scutaro
B-Mark DeRosa
B-Carlos Delgado
B-Willy Taveras
B-Matt Wieters


Jair Jurrjens
Ted Lilly
Francisco Rodríguez
Brad Ziegler
Jonathan Sánchez
Matt Garza
Gil Meche
Jake Peavy

[MadDog36]

Your team is shaky you need some POWER in that lineup.

Try offering Scutaro/Fukudome for Zimm, but you might should consider accepting his offer as it stands now though.

You don't HAVE to have Dero. his utility positions help but I'd shoot for the upgrade. you have the thin positions covered.

[Hit Factory]

I like this trade for you since Zimmerman is a pretty nice upgrade from Mora. However you have to test the waters and see what the other owners in your league think of Scutaro in order to find out his "true market value." I think you could possibly squeeze a little more out of the Zimmerman owner.

[JohnnnyD]

should i try to offer him scutaro and fukudome to keep some power with DeRosa?

[Hit Factory]

Yeah, try offering Fukudome, then once you get Zimmerman I would try and deal DeRosa Derek Lee for a Joey Votto type player.