Is this another "no brainer"

[roundBallJef]

I just got offered Dustin Pedroia and Jason Werth for my Aaron Hill. I don't need Werth, but Pedroia is VERY enticing.

Is this a no-brainer, or does Hill have that much potential?

Thanks, WHIR

[MadDog36]

Well you can't expect a season from Hill like he had, but he's no fluke. The guy is 27 (prime age), had all kinds of potential for a breakout and seems to be finally over the injury bug.

I'd rather get an upside pitcher or prospect in deal to make it better.

Pedroia cna flat out rake though.

[Hit Factory]

LOL I have no idea why the other owner would want to swap Pedroia for Hill? At the moment they are a wash, but I trust Pedroia over the course of an entire season a lot more than Hill. If you get Pedroia you can't lose in this deal because there is no way he will put up worse numbers than Hill, you are getting a more secure player and I would make this deal in a heartbeat.

[Howie]

Yeah, its a no-brainer. The AL MVP for a hot start sell-high player (although Hill is for real, he isn't THIS good).

[cstorms]

Yes its a no brainer!

viewtopic.php?t=382199