Holliday for Lincecum

[rjforlife]

I give Lincecum/Chris Davis/Elijah Dukes. I get Matt Holliday/Josh Johnson/Joey Votto. Pretty much 1b/sp/of for 1b/sp/of so I won't post teams but I need a little hitting help and my pitching is in good shape. Should I pull the trigger on this? Its a 9 team 5x5 roto. We start 9 pitchers and 14 players on offense. Non-keeper.


Drop your link ill respond asap..

[djxskillz]

hmm close. I might stay put. I don't like holiday at all this year and Chris Davis should turn it around. Lincy will be a lot better than josh johnson.

[bozack4813]

I would do that trade i think holliday is too good to keep struggling so hard and josh johnson isnt that far a step down but joey votto is going to have a great year

help with mine pls viewtopic.php?t=382043

[rotoquest]

I like the trade for you. Davis is overrated, but votto is the real deal. JJ is an excellent pitcher & holliday will produce.

please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=382042

[xcyanksxc]

I see a lot of positives and negatives to this trade. Holliday/Johnson/Votto is probably the better package but onnly if Holliday starts to hit. I don't know if he will being out of Colorado. Lincecum, on the other hand, is easily the best player in the deal.

I would favor holding onto what you got or if your pitching is deep try and get someone other than Holliday (Rios comes to mind).

[zedtech78]

Thanks for the help w/ mine!

Who else is on your pitching staff?

I'm a big JJ and JV fan so I'm leaning towards pulling the trigger but if the rest of your pitching staff isn't that great then that can change my whole outlook.

[rjforlife]

Greinke/Joba/Zambrano/Danks/Garza/Lohse/Hughes/Ubaldo/Ricky Romero(DL) is the rest of my staff. Not amazing but add Josh Johnson and its really a respectable staff for a 9 teamer as I play matchups each week and usually come out with 6-7 solid spots each week.......