I just vote it down for the heck of it.
EDIT: Alright, if I could be serious for a minute, try putting the rankings in a table perhaps (rank, player, comments) to give the rankings a cleaner look. You should also make a short comment on each player. You don't have to update the comments on every single player each week, just enough to give it a little more player insight. A little wrap-up before listing the rankings would be a nice touch; something like a stock watch highlighting which players are up and down, and why.
BTW, you and rooks ever thought of doing the Cafe's version of Funston's Big Board?