Shields for Greinke?

[silverZ]

Straight up in 5x5 roto who would you rather have?

[B-Chad]

Coming into the year I would have given a slight nod to Shields based on a slightly longer track record and his impecable control. However, given the hot start for Greinke, and the great strikeout potential I'm not afraid to say I'm changing my tune. The fact is, Greinke has ace pedigree/potential, Shields, though very good, stable, reliable, and a top end number 2 starter in 12 team leagues does not have ace potential like Greinke.

[chargersfan36]

Greinke for the K's. His ERA should at least match Shields with a solid WHIP.

viewtopic.php?t=381893