Roy Halladay/Ichiro for Magglio/Phillips/Kazmir WHIR

[Tayma]

Im being offered Ordonez, Phillips, and Kazmir For Halladay and Ichiro

My Line Up is:
C
Russell Martin
1B
Lance Berkman
2B
Chase Utley
3B
David Wright
SS
Troy Tulowitzki
LF
Raúl Ibañez
CF
Ichiro Suzuki
RF
Jermaine Dye
OF
Bobby Abreu
Util
Nelson Cruz
BN
Andre Ethier

SP
Roy Halladay
SP
Rich Harden
SP
Yovani Gallardo
SP
Kyle Lohse (Add/Drop for Avaliable Prob.)
SP
Joe Saunders (Add/Drop for Avaliable Prob.)
RP
Brad Lidge
RP
Francisco Cordero
RP
Matt Lindstrom
BN
Clayton Kershaw
(LAD - SP)

[smoovethug]

I'd accept this. You're getting the best player in the deal in Phillips, you downgrade SPs some but Kazmir has the ability to be as good as Halladay if he puts it all together and stays healthy. Magglio still has enough in the tank to be pretty effective. The only thing about this trade is that you'd be without a CF but you'd be left with enough excess pieces to trade for a good one.

[Tayma]

Chris Young Clears Waviers Tonight. Should i pick him up?


Should I drop one of the pitchers and have both of my Bench Players Be offensive?

So as of now im going to need to Drop 2 of Either/Cruz/Saunders/Lohse correct?

[smoovethug]

Saunders and Lohse would be my drops. Doesn't hurt to add Young as he should heat up soon. Cruz, Ethier, Dye, Abreu are all pieces that you could use to try to get a CF of similar value.

[Tayma]

TYVM for the trade advice I Accepted it.

[plainyogurt]

I think its a close call...

Halladay to me is much better than Kazmir...Magglio is not the same..will get you less power(look at cabrera..he is on fire and magglio still not hitting HR)...Phillips is struggling..

I would be happy with Ichiro and Halladay... I wouldnt do it..
\

Help me out

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381843&p=3054632#p3054632