Hamilton for Ethier???

[BRoyFanClub]

Should I trade Ethier to get Josh Hamilton.

I'm in a 10 team, 6x6 league with OBP & SLG replacing AVG, 10 keeper league. Here's my current roster:

C- Y.Molina, Mauer (DL)
1B- Teixeira
2B- Roberts
3B- Lowell, Atkins
SS- Rollins
OF- Sizermore, Ichiro, Ethier, Bruce, Choo, Fowler
SP- Nolasco, C.Lee, Lackey (DL), Cain, Slowey, Scherzer, Lilly, Lowe
RP- Arredondo, Putz, Kuo, R.Franklin

I've got good depth in the OF so I think I could ride out Hamilton's slump and rib injury... the question is, was Hamilton's last season a fluke or is he legit long term? Is he a better keeper than Ethier?

[4ToTheStadium]

PULL THE TRIGGER NOWWWWW

[Chicago 2]

Yes, pull the trigger.

Sell high while you can to get Hamilton.


viewtopic.php?t=381812

[SOUTHSIDE HITMEN]

He's not going to give you JHam for Either.

[smoovethug]

In a heartbeat.

[Tayma]

Are you offering this trade?

or was this trade offered to you?


If the guy is stupid enough to accept/offer this trade then yes!

[marc1313]

I'm a Dodger fan, but if this was offered to you, INSTA ACCEPT NOW before he changes his mind.

[SDDECK]

If you are offering this trade the only way he will accept is if they are so drunk they miss the decline button and hits accept.

[BRoyFanClub]

I offered him another trade and this came up in our counter-offer discussion.... his idea

[SDDECK]

I offered him another trade and this came up in our counter-offer discussion.... his idea

Then push the accept button and don't think twice and then pitch him another trade and see what kind of ridiculous counter offer he comes back with.