Santana/Rollins Deal - Should I Pull the Trigger?

[jmcampbe11]

Is this trade worth considering? Keep in mind, my pitching is stacked and I need offense.

GIVE------------GET
J.Santana-----Rollins
Ellsbury-------A.Ramirez
Atkins--------Hawpe
Napoli--------Headley

MY TEAM (10 Team Roto)
C-Napoli 1b-Teixiera 2b-Alx.Ramirez ss-*Drew 3b-Atkins CI-A.Gonzalez MI-J.Lopez
OF-Holliday, Kemp, T.Hunter, Ellsbury, Bradley Util-Reynolds

SP-J.Santana, Liriano, Gallardo, Bedard, Wainwright, *Dice-K
RP-Broxton, Jenks, Bell, Sherrill

Bench-Weiters (also have a waiver claim in for Soto)

[jmcampbe11]

I think I'm talking myself into making this trade. Thoughts?

[davdav]

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh...rollins is struggling...Johan is the man...Bedard did bad last game...I like ellsbury...
don't do it

[dycwang]

See if you can get more for Ellsbury.

[YakittyYak]

I like this trade for your team. Ramirez is a huge upgrade over Atkins and you can afford to lose the 15-20 sb difference between Rollins and Ellsbury. This trade will make you stacked at the corners with Teixeira, AGonz, and ARam. Rollins, Drew, and Alexei will also be a nice trio for you in the middle once Drew returns. Also, in a 10-teamer, you shouldn't have any problem replacing Napoli until Weiters gets called up. Your pitching will obviously take a hit losing Santana and I would maybe try to see if he'll throw in a decent pitcher in place of Hawpe or Headley. Overall I think this would be a good trade for you though.

Please help with mine: http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=381809

[jmcampbe11]

I just countered by asking for C.Davis (as opposed to Headley). Any better?

[meotraix]

Thanks for helping with mine!

I like the deal. I think Chris Davis does make the deal better although Headley is quieting putting together a solid statline. My opinion on everything else is pretty similar to YakkityYak.

[lyons595]

Eventhough you have good SP, I think you need to get more for Johan. Rolins is a 'buy low' guy right now and you should have to give Johan to get him. Plus you have a few guys in your rotation who haven't ever 'done it' for a whole year so some depth and a true stud SP will balance that. Dont do it.