SOSA or GILES.....

[Clevelander]

who would you rather have and why...?

[DJUmperPSU]

giles, b/c i dont like sosa, haha

[Fluidoz]

That's a good question. Sammy will hit more dingers. Giles will steal more bases. Avg. will be pretty close. Maybe a slight edge to Giles. Rbi's going to Sammy and probably runs to him as well. I think the Cubs a loaded. Therefore I'd take Sammy. But not by much.

[orangecrushv]

I'd take Giles, K's count in my league

-Rich

[DJUmperPSU]

step right up and greet the mets

[prodpaul]

I'd take Giles, K's count in my league

-Rich

Same here Rich.

[jonnyblack]

That's a good question. Sammy will hit more dingers. Giles will steal more bases. Avg. will be pretty close. Maybe a slight edge to Giles. Rbi's going to Sammy and probably runs to him as well. I think the Cubs a loaded. Therefore I'd take Sammy. But not by much.

Giles isnt going to swipe anymore bags, he doesnt have anything left in his knees, and i just cant see botchy risking an inhury to such a pure hitter. Sosa is solid, almost as solid (predictable) as chipper jones. I'd go with Sosa all the way to the bank.

[Pedantic]

I like Giles, because he puts up great numbers, has a better average, and can be had a couple rounds later in the draft.

[Pogotheostrich]

Sosa is solid, almost as solid (predictable) as chipper jones. I'd go with Sosa all the way to the bank.

You have got to be kidding? Sosa is in a clear decline and to call him predictable as Chipper is laughable.

[wp001g]

giles