I trade Halladay/Jeter for Utley/Theriot? WHIR

[meotraix]

A guy offered me Utley/Theriot for Halladay/Jeter. No-brainer trade?

Yahoo, H2H, standard cats...
My team:

Iannetta
V-Mart
Hudson
Wright
Jeter
Carlos Lee
Fukudome
BJ Upton
Granderson
McClouth
Lind

Halladay
Felix Hernandez
Qualls
Scott Downs
Harang
Cueto
Zambrano
Jurrjens
Wandy Rodriguez
Phill Hughes
DL - BJ Ryan

[TeamMikeDeveraux]

Yes Yes Yes!!
Utley is the best player in the deal. I think Theriot is equal to Jeter for the most part. Sure Halladay is good, but he pitches in the AL East against some really good offenses. Utley is a 1st round talent and you arent getting killed in the SS department either. Do this quick!! I hope this helped

Help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381767

[cobbs87]

Agreed. Honestly Theriot and Jeter are comparable now a days. So let's rephrase...Halladay for Utley? Absolutely.

Your pitching has a lot of upside. You will be losing your only discernible ace, but you should be able to sustain your pitching. One of your pitchers is more than bound to exceed is value. Definite no brainer.

Thanks for the help with mine btw.

[bossoaks]

Why not!! Utley will help and Theriot and Jeter or similar. I like the deal. Plus, I'm an LSU grad so I would always lean towards Theriot anyway.

[url]viewtopic.php?t=381811[/url]

[jmcampbe11]

Do it. Especially in HtoH leagues where starting pitching is devalued, because you can stream.

Can you return the favor plz viewtopic.php?t=381810

PS) The comment about Theriot being as good as Jeter is a bit of stretch though.

[dycwang]

I think Jeter is a little underrated considering the new hitter friendly Yankee Stadium. That said, Utley > Halladay. Do the deal.

[Chicago 2]

Yes!!!

In a heartbeat. Utley would improve your team at 2B and Theriot is not a bad option at SS.

Whomever offered you that is selling low on Utley.


viewtopic.php?t=381812

[meotraix]

Just to update...

The trade became...

I trade:
Jeter
Halladay
Granderson
Fukudome

I get:
Utley
Theriot
Bedard
Kemp

[coma]

Just to update...

The trade became...

I trade:
Jeter
Halladay
Granderson
Fukudome

I get:
Utley
Theriot
Bedard
Kemp

Do it. Kemp + Utley = DIRTY!!! Plus Bedard has been playing well. You're getting a pretty big steal here.


Help?
viewtopic.php?t=381902