Big Papi for Jermaine Dye

[galacticat]

Take Papi, right?

[yanks2327]

I don't think it's that simple - Papi's been trending downwards for going on 2 seasons now, and Dye's been a consistent fantasy performer, even as he ages. Papi may operate in a slightly more productive lineup, but I like Dye's average over Papi's, and these days I like his power more too. I'd definitely prefer Dye, even more so if it's a H2H for his consistency.

Help w/ my topic: viewtopic.php?t=381697

[Coalminer]

I actually have to go with Dye too. I know that the Red Sox lineup can be impressive but Papi's numbers have been trending down. Also without Manny around I don't know how many good pitches he will really see. I think Dye's numbers will be better this year.

[kimchi_chigae]

I trust Dye a lot more than I trust Ortiz at this point.