Billingsley for Peavy?

[Newkie]

Hi, I am in a 10 keeper, 10 manager H2H league with normal 5x5 scoring. Would you do this trade if you were me.
Heres my team and the keepers from last yr.
Mauer Keeper
Adrian Gonzalez keeper
Uggla keeper
M.Young
Aramis Ramirez keeper
Sizemore keeper
Beltran keeper
Bay keeper
Ellsbury
Adams

James Shields keeper
Billingsley
Cliff Lee keeper
Nolasco
Josh Johnson
Kuroda
Jurjjens
Lohse
Washburn

Thanks

[Padres Fan]

this is a hard one, clearly Peavy is a elite pitcher, but runs a risk of injuries, also who knows if he will get traded this season and it depends on where too?, Billingsley is still kinda unknown in terms on his abilities but he does play for a good team, so the wins will come and he does great stuff, IMO though I would get Peavy seeing as your pitching needs help.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381619

[Newkie]

Thanks, actually I had Kazmir until a week ago when I traded him for Ellsbury. I needed the steals, and to be honest, my pitching staff has probably the most depth in the league. Just not the ellite pitcher.
Anymore out there with a suggestion or two.

Thanks

[Newkie]

Any body else out there with an opinion. I am leaning towards taking Peavy, but its not a sure thing.

Thanks

[Yanks Ruined It]

I would stand pat, I like the fact that Billingsly will(should) get more wins and as said before Peavy does have some DL downside, other cats are even IMO

[BSbludolf]

You do have an elite pitcher in Billingsley. I dont have him this year but I did have him last year and he was a stud. Peavy is overrated and his violent delivery will keep him on the DL a lot. Keep what you got