nathan/ibanez for carlos lee and granderson WHIR

[fierro33]

i give up nathan/ibanez for carlos lee and granderson


is this a no-brainer? i am reading about carlos lee and his injured leg and how it could affect his power


10 team 5x5 h2h

C Ianetta (Weiters)
1b Pena
2b Derosa
3b Wright
ss Reyes
OF Abreu
OF Ibanez
OF Ellsbury
Util Wells (Arod)
pablo sandoval
dexter fowler

Lincecum
Sabathia
Peavy
Burnett
Gallardo
Baker
Slowey
Wandy


Papelbon
Nathan
Soria
Lidge
Ryan
Morrow

[fierro33]

anyone?

[chodaboy]

You definitely have the depth to lose nathan since you have so many closers. However, i feel Ibanez is gonna do well in Philly, as he's already shown. Lee I've always felt is streaky and will only net you a handful more homers more than Ibanez. And I don't see where you'd play Granderson. I think a better play for you would be to take those two and maybe shop for a 2b to upgrade Derosa.

[mac-unit]

Yea, you should do this. You have more then enough RP depth and I like Ibanez this season but Lee and Granderson are too good to pass up imo.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=381571

[MadDog36]

You need the OF upgrades, but Ibanez in Philly has turned into a real steal for his owners. Much as like Carlos, and you have the depth at RP. Oh shoot go for it.

[jase218]

I think you should probably do it but I want to caution you about a few things. You do have great RP depth BUT think about this. Soria has a potential injury and will be held out for about a week. Ryan is on the DL and his velocity has been way down. Lidge is battling a soar knee and it is said to be the cause of his poor start so far. Morrow didn't pitch over the weekend due to shoulder soarness. Papelbon is a stud and i think Nathan will end up as a top closer. I think Lee and Granderson are too much to pass up, but just be concerned.



Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381459
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381454