Would one of these deals help me? WHIR

[coma]

I am trying to do a trade in which I give up more players (including Valverde) to get an upgrade at a position and use the extra spot to grab F. Fransisco. After doing some looking I came up with two possible trades. Would one of these trades help me more? Would they get vetoed?

Trade A:
I give: Aram, Furcal (he needs SS), and Valverde
I get: A-Rod, and a throw in (Stephen Drew since he is injured? Or someone I would probably drop for Mike Lowell/Chris Davis)
I may be giving up a lot, but A-Rod would be nice.. Aram is incredibly consistent on the other hand.

Trade B:
I give: Morneau and Valverde
I get: Teixiera (team name is Yankees Suck)
This probably has a greater chance of getting accepted..

8 team H2H league.
Hitter cats are R/H/HR/RBI/SB/AVG/OBP.
Pitcher cats are IP/W/SV/HR/K/ERA/WHIP.

C- McCann
1B- Morneau
2B- Pedroia
3B- Aramis
SS- Jeter
OF- Sizemore
OF- Hart
OF- Ethier
Util- Votto
BN- Furcal
BN- Bruce
BN- Hill

SP- Santana
SP- Billingsley
RP- Valverde
RP- Capps
P- Bell
P- Oswalt
P- Greinke
BN- Bedard
BN- Verlander

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd make the 2nd deal. I like Tex slightly more than Morneau and you can pick up
Fransisco to replace Valverde.

[bajatodd]

I think both trades would get approved. As an AROD owner I am praying he comes back and rakes but there are zero guarentees he is the same player.

Valverde is on a bad team this year and Saves may be tough to come by. Drew if heathly is in the same ballpark as furcal in my opinion. I am not a huge Tex fan so I would take trade A.

[LetsGoYankees]

Both trades look good for you, I don't think either would get vetoed. I like trade A, furcal is just rotting on your bench..and Aramis is very consistent, but is prone to injury, although he usually only misses 20 games or so.

[dagactor]

I'd go the ARod route as well...and Lowell and Davis should not be available for pickup! I think both will have great years.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381599

[Eightan]

I like trade A better. A-Rod is better then A-Ram and Drew is fair for Furcal and Valverde makes up the difference.