Sizemore/M-Cab Trade - Good Move for Me?

[jmcampbe11]

Assuming Hamilton's healthy what do you think of this trade? Am I getting enough in return? I'm struggling in batting avg, that's why I'm considering trading Sizemore.

GIVE-----------GET
Sizemore-----Mig.Cabrera
Hamilton-----Markakis
Galllardo-----Halladay
Reynolds-----Choo

For context, this is a 10 team modified keeper league (we keep three players). Right now my keepers would be Sizemore, Hamilton, and Longoria.

MY TEAM
c-martin 1b-gonzalez 2b-phillips ss-alx.ramirez 3b-longoria ci-reynolds mi-lopez of-sizemore, hamilton, dye, wells, adm.jones util-crisp sp-greinke, gallardo, nolasco, lilly, r.johnson, *smoltz rp-broxton, qualls, morrow, percival, cruz, ray

[jmcampbe11]

Anyone?

[jmcampbe11]

Need some feedback folks. I'm on the fence. WHIR.

[mak1277]

I would definitely make this deal, I actually feel like it favors you quite a bit (but I also think markakis is not much of a downgrade at all from Hamilton).

[WyldStallyn]

pretty even deal. if youre comfortable with markakis as a keeper you can go for it, but it really just comes down to personal preference

[jmcampbe11]

pretty even deal. if youre comfortable with markakis as a keeper you can go for it, but it really just comes down to personal preference

I think I'm just as comfortable with Markakis as Hamilton. Also like Cabrera as a keeper more then Sizemore so I'm thinking it might be worth it. Also plus is Halladay would help stabilize my pitching staff a bit. Greinke's been lights out, but everyone else (Gallardo, Nolasco, Lilly, RJ) have been inconsistent.

[jmcampbe11]

Anyone else?

[jmcampbe11]

Any other thoughts? Good trade? Bad trade?

[steevie]

i likethis trade.
i def. prefer mCab over sizemore and also markakis over hamilton..just a personal preference. i would do it everyday..