Kinsler Trade... Soriano + Utley

[NikeTxGuy]

I would be trading away Kinsler + Sabathia and getting Soriano + Utley... is this a good trade?

[NikeTxGuy]

my outfielders are Torii Hunter, Curtis Granderson, Josh Hamilton, and Johnny Damon.

[mojoorising]

would help to see full roster including pitchers

[NikeTxGuy]

MY TEAM:

C - B. MOLINA
1B - C. PENA, R. HOWARD, P. KONERKO
2B - I. KINSLER, H. KENDRICK
3B - J. CANTU
SS - M. SCUTARO
OF - T. HUNTER
OF - C. GRANDERSON
OF - J. DAMON
OF - J. HAMILTON


SP - J. SANTANA
SP - C. SABATHIA
SP - G. MECHE
SP - A. GALARRAGA
SP - J. SAUNDERS

RP - PAPELBON
RP - SHERILL
RP - FRANKLIN
RP - WEATHERS
RP - FRASOR
RP - HOFFMAN

[mojoorising]

I dont think so other then CC and santana your pitching is mediocre... i would try and trade for SS upgrade if anything since your OF is fairly solid

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=381487

[NikeTxGuy]

Anyone else??? bump

[WyldStallyn]

kinsler and utley are basically even, so it comes down to soriano vs sabathia. i dont think you cant handle the loss of sabathia to your pitching staff

[NikeTxGuy]

what if i wanted to tank? Hugely increasing my batting power?

[NikeTxGuy]

Another option I had was to trade Papelbon instead of C.C.? I wouldn't be getting Soriano back, but I'll have to see who'd I get instead.

[cassplaya4]

Hey man I would not trade Kinsler for anyone right now especially for what you are getting in this trade.

Albeit Soriano and Utley are monsters, Kinsler is a 5 tool guy about to have an amazing year and I would recommend holding onto him for the moment.

Hope my opinion helps.


viewtopic.php?t=381587