Webb, Verlander, & Rollins for CC, Liriano, & Escobar?

[henncoop]

I was recently offered CC Sabathia, Randy Johnson & SS Escobar for Webb, Verlander & Rollins
Quite a cloudy mystery with players hurt & vastly under-performing . I rejected the offer but countered with the same substituting Liriano for Johnson in his side of the offer given Johnson's age but Liriano is a risk as well. Seems the only sure thing in this deal right now isCC has a good year & Rollins will most likely rebound ...the rest seems quite risky on both sides . I'm a bit of a newbie although I won my free league last year & have a few leagues this year but I hardly consider myself a roto expert.
So what do you guys think? Any input?

[dycwang]

I'd prefer the Rollins side of the deal.

Rollins > CC.
Webb > Liriano
Verlander > Escobar

I'd only do this if you desperately need pitching as CC + Liriano > Webb + Verlander. However, you're giving up too much going from Rollins to Escobar.