Soriano/C Lee for V-Mart WHIR

[Turd Sandwich]

10 team H2H points league where lineups set weekly. We can start 2 MI, 2CI, 3 OF, 1 DH, 1 C, 2SP, 2 RP and 1 extra SP/RP.
I would give Soriano or Carlos Lee for Victor Martinez. I could put Bruce in at one of my OF spots or DH. I still would have 4 strong OFs. I know that I need SPs, but I don't know that I can pass this deal up. What do you think? Will help with yours!

Here is my lineup.

C- Ianetta
MI-Hardy
MI- Roberts
CI- Longoria
CI- Berkman
OF- Braun
OF-Soriano
OF C Lee
DH- Nelson Cruz

Bench: Jay Bruce, Chris Davis, Stephen Drew

SPS: Harden, Liriano, Scherzer, Baker, Chamberlain, Phil Hughes
RP: Broxton, Jenks
DL: Lackey, Carpenter

[jmcampbe11]

I understand where you're coming from wanting to upgrade your catcher slot, but you're getting HAMMERED in terms of value on this trade. I think you're giving up way too much.

Can you return the favor plz - viewtopic.php?t=381339

[Turd Sandwich]

This is only one of the guys not both. I don't think that their value is that much more than V Mart since he seems to have returned to his old form.

[jmcampbe11]

My mistake. I still think you're overpaying. If we drafted both would still go before V-Mart. If I had to choose I'd trade Lee though.

[dycwang]

You're giving up way too much. Shop for a better deal. I wouldn't trade either for a catcher.

[ike301]

My mistake. I still think you're overpaying. If we drafted both would still go before V-Mart. If I had to choose I'd trade Lee though.

yup. agreed.

[Fender1114]

Yep, both are defintely more valuable. I think VMart will be great this year, but they will both outproduce him. I think you are just freakign out cuz Ianetta has been so awful, but be patient. He will come around soon. If anything I would rather trade Bruce in aVMart deal than either of those 2 studs.

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381360