Do I use my #3 Waiver on Brandon Phillips? WHIR!

[Therobsclub]

Do I try and get him with my #3 Waiver or do I wait for something better to come along later in the year? If I do get him who do I drop? Hill, Cantu, or Carp.

I'm thinking Once Arod comes back Cantu has very little value on my team. Maybe I should try and package Hill and Cantu in a deal for a closer/SP?

C - Jorge Posada
1b - Albert Pujols
2b - Aaron Hill
3b - Chipper Jones
SS - Michael Young
OF - Johnny Damon
OF - Raul Ibanez
OF - Jacoby Ellsbury
Util - Jorge Cantu
BN - Vlad - DL
DL - Alex Rodriguez

SP - Josh Beckett
SP - CC Sabathia
RP - Bobby Jenks
RP - Jonathon Broxton
P - Matt Lindstrom
P - Javier Vazquez
P - Joba Chamberlain
BN Chris Young
BN Chris Carpenter -DL
BN Edinson Volquez
BN Matt Cain

Yahoo Keeper H2H League 2 hitters 2 pitchers. Standard scoring plus (Cycle, Grand Slam - Complete Game, No Hitter)

Yahoo H2H league- 10 teams Keeper: 2 batters, 2 pitchers

[Howie]

I'd drop Carp. Phillips went 30-30 two years ago and 20-20 last year as a 2B, and now people are dropping him because he's had a bad few weeks. lol.

[kidsilk]

I would pick up Phillips using my #3 ww priority for sure. IF you are in a league with smart owners that know what they are doing then you won't have a better player to pick up down the line. But, if you are in a league with guys who dont know what's up, hold on to your ww priority and maybe Pujols will get dropped. But, seriously, pick him up.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=381098

[Justblaze]

I'd drop Carp. But Hill and Cantu could be dropped as well. I'd definitely try to get Phillips with #3 Waiver. I'd be surprised if they guys with #1 or #2 waiver doesn't use it.

[ajk23az]

Yeah you should use it.
And like others said, drop Carpenter.

Please help;
viewtopic.php?f=94&t=381319&p=3050539#p3050539

[WyldStallyn]

i cant imagine anything better will come along. use the claim and hope you get him. and i agree with dropping carp

[saemick]

no brainer. Pick him up & drop Carp

please help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381295

[uhhhjboy]

I would do it. I'm holding Phillips right now till he realizes the season's already started. Once you get him you could probably get a decent return on a trade with Hill while he's hot.

[Darth Danielus]

So perpelexing how many people seem to be dropping this guy...who's top 5 at least at a fairly scarce position. Why not try to deal him first?
Anyways...yes, use your #3 waiver spot on him -- if the guys ahead of have any sense at all however, you won't get him.

[davdav]

Go for it! He got dropped by the last place team in my league, and i got him with 7th waiver spot!
PLEASE HELP!!!
viewtopic.php?t=381328