Are these decent offers for Braun/Utley?? WHIR

[rib217]

I'm not sure if I should attempt to send these offers over or not; are they close?

I give: Greinke
I get: Utley

I give: Greinke; Rios
I get: Braun

The other managers rotation is: Peavy; Baker; Weaver; Lester; Wakefield and just added Washburn

He's in the bottom of most of the pitching categories right now, but are these offers good enough to start trade talks?

12 team roto re-draft (My Team)
R HR RBI SB K Avg Obp-----W L QS K Sv Era Whip

C- Pablo
1b- Morneau
2b- K.J
3b- Miggy
SS- Jeter
Of- Lee; Hart; Rios
UT- Adrian; Snider
Bn- Matsui; Peralta; Ian Stewart

SP- Shields; Greinke; Gallardo; Young; J. Zimmerman; Carpenter DL
RP- Gonzalez; Hoffman; Downs; Ray

[hett2333]

I'd give up greinke for utley without question...

viewtopic.php?t=381267

[Hey Hermano]

I think it's way too early to consider dumping 1st-round level guys like Utley and Braun for pitching help. If he's smart, he stays put.

I wouldn't send those offers over. You'd have to probably at least give up Lee to get Peavy.

pick me a CATCHER? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381278

[hett2333]

I think it's way too early to consider dumping 1st-round level guys like Utley and Braun for pitching help. If he's smart, he stays put.

I wouldn't send those offers over. You'd have to probably at least give up Lee to get Peavy.

pick me a CATCHER? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381278

read the question next time, he's giving up Greinke to get Utley...

[MemphisTigerFan10]

I agree....Utley is a great player and I would really consider doing this...

Please Help:
viewtopic.php?t=381302

[BALCO All-Stars]

It never hurts to try, but IMO that's not nearly enough for 1st round talent...

[bcbhockey68]

If you can do it then do it, it never hurt to try. However I wouldn't go for that, but I did just trade Pedroia(not a first but generally a 2nd rounder) for Grienke with other players, but still.

Please help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=381308

[WyldStallyn]

doesnt seem like most of the responders actually read your post

unless the guy you want to trade with has a serious crush on greinke and is hating on utley or braun, theres no way that gets accepted. i dont think you should even offer it. might offend the other manager and make him unwilling to deal with you in the future