Hill or Pedroia?

[Galileo]

Which of these two would you prefer to keep and what could I expect to get in trade for the other from the team listed below?

I Rodriguez
R Howard
F Lopez
A Ramirez
J Peralta
C Beltran
Jason Bay
M Kemp
J Votto
Bench: I Stewart, R Ankiel

A Wainwright
B Lidge
B Myers
B Wilson
C Qualls
D Haren
G Meche

Bench
J Maine
K Escobar
K Davies
M Garza
M Scherzer
U Jimenez



My team:
C- Suzuki
1B - Delgado
2B - Hill
SS - J. Reyes
3B - Cantu
OF - Granderson, Lee, Duncan
DH - Pedroia
Bench - Kubel, Blalock, Atkins, Guerrero, Wieters

Pitching (start 7)
SP - Beckett, Cain, Gallaraga, Volquez, A. Reyes, Pelfrey, Lackey
RP - Bell, Broxton, Rodney

[slink]

Well I would prefer to keep Pedroia but he is ridiculously overrated. If you could get a great return for Pedroia I don't think you'll miss him too much with Hill as your 2B this year. From Hill I expect .290 average and 15+ HR.

Help please?

[Bjorne Greece]

If you're going to trade one away I'd trade Pedroia away. He has the flashier name and could get more in return if you are really outsmarting your trading partner.

See if you can get a closer for him. I'm not sure what bats the other guy would be willing to give up for a 2B. I'm not crazy about Rodney on your team.

[bobbydigital82]

bay/votto for pedrioa/someone else...

throw it out there... if can get that done... it would be sweet -

viewtopic.php?t=381090

[Galileo]

If you're going to trade one away I'd trade Pedroia away. He has the flashier name and could get more in return if you are really outsmarting your trading partner.

See if you can get a closer for him. I'm not sure what bats the other guy would be willing to give up for a 2B. I'm not crazy about Rodney on your team.

I'm not real crazy about Rodney either, but I have Broxton and Bell so Rodney is a third option. I can only play 7 pitchers per week so two closers with an emergency backup is plenty for me.

The other guy would prefer to trade pitching rather than bats.