Need an SP! Good deal for Harang? WHIR

[Fender1114]

With Webb hurt, I'm down to 3 SPs (not counting Hughes). Was just offered Harang for Phillips/Buccholz. Any reason not to accept this?

10 team, roto (QS instead of Wins)

MY TEAM

C: B. Molina
1B: J. Morneau
2B: O. Hudson
3B: Ar. Ramirez
SS: M. Young
OF: Ca. Lee
OF: A. Dunn
OF: W. Taveras
UTL: P. Konerko
B: M. Lowell
B: N. Swisher
B: B. Phillips
B: K. Fukodome

SP: J. Santana
SP: Cl. Lee
RP: F. Rodriguez
RP: C. Qualls
P: F. Rodney
P: R. Soriano
P: O. Dotel
B: A. Galarraga
B: P. Hughes
B: C. Buccholz
DL: B. Webb

[smoovethug]

Bad deal for you. Even if Harang bounces all the way back to his old form, which he's capable of, I'd still shoot for more for a 30/30 2B in Phillips.

[jweb2244]

Don't sell low on Phillips - he will come around.

[cstorms]

Don't accept this deal. Its too early to sell low on someone like Phillips. Do not do this.

mine viewtopic.php?t=381062

[Howie]

I agree with the above posts, if you're going to deal Phillips, you should be able to get a top 10 SP in return.

[NickC19]

Definitely dont do this deal. As others have said, you could get more than Harang most likely...

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=381067