Help on Trade offered to me. whir

[kevn77]

I was just offered Zambrano and Corey Hart for my Cain and Adam Dunn. 12 team roto, points are-SBs, runs, rbi, total bases, obp, kd9, wins, whip, era, saves. My team is=

Soto, Geovany C
Loney, James 1B
Ramirez, Alexei 2B
Longoria, Evan 3B TB
Scutaro, Marco SS TOR
Lee, Carlos N. LF HOU
Hunter, Torii CF ANA
Cruz, Nelson R. RF TEX
Dunn, Adam LF WAS
Dukes, Elijah RF WAS

Cain, Matt SP SF
Gallardo, Yovani SP MIL
Haren, Dan SP ARI
Kershaw, Clayton SP
Vazquez, Javier SP ATL
Qualls, Chad RP ARI
Wilson, Brian RP SF

Reserve Batters
Cabrera, Orlando SS OAK
Drew, Stephen SS ARI
Spilborghs, Ryan RF COL
Lind, Adam LF TOR

Reserve Pitchers
Parra, Manny SP
Sanchez, Jonathan O. SP SF

Minors Batters
LaPorta, Matt OF CLE M


Thanks for the help. Leave a link

[Howie]

Dunn is a monster in an OBP league, I would keep him. Cain and Zambrano are pretty equal, I'd rather have Cain though.

[kevn77]

The only reason I wasnt sure is cause I am dead last in SBs and was last in runs untill the last couple days I am now is about 7th in runs, and not far behind others. But still not sure, harts speed is tempting and Dunn being in washingtons offense is tad scarey. (SBs are only half points also)

[plapre3]

No deal.

Dunn in an OBP league is a thirst tier OF, which is very valuable. Inversely, Hart and his .299 obp last year (YUK) falls all the way to the 6th or 7th tier. With Cain and Zambrano roughly equals (personally, I like Cain better), the deal isn't even close.

Don't give up .100 pts in OBP and 20 homers just to get 20 steals.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=381039

[zainfidel]

Wow, if SBs are only 1/2 point, I would punt them. I would much rather have Cain than Zambrano, and I wouldn't worry about Dunn. The anemic National offense has not hurt his production yet. I like Hart, but not for what you'd have to give up. If you really want SBs, I'm sure you could find someone on waivers that will provide that stat.

[jweb2244]

I have liked Hart since having him as a rookie, but I think people tend to overrate him (including me), and I think Cain will have a big year, so agree with above posters.

Can you help with mine (don't know how to post link but posts near yours)? Thanks.