Deep league trade: R. Weeks for C. Davis?

[sowen246]

16 team mixed 5x5

I've been offered R. Weeks for my C. Davis.

I need a 2b, although a. Cabrerra has been filling in well. Davis looks totally lost at the plate, but he has power potential....
Also, someone just dropped P. Palanco; is he an upgrade over Cabrerra?
What do you think?

My roster:

C: K. Suzuki
1b: C. Pena
2b: A Cabrerra
ss: J. Bartlett
3b: M. Teahan
of: G. Sizemore
of: M. Ramierez
of: R. Ludwick
of: R. Ankiel
u: C. Crisp
P: J. Sheilds
P: E. Volquez
P: J. Jurjens
P: P. Maholm
P: R. Wolf
p: M. Gonzalez
P: T. Hoffman
P: J. Cruz

bn: J. Smoltz
bn: C. Davis
bn: C. Duncan
bn: B. Gardner

[MaudDib]

Keep Davis. Cabrera is handling things pretty well right now and Weeks is not much of an upgrade (if he is an upgrade at all). I probably would pick up Polanco as well but don't drop Cabrera for him.

[Howie]

I don't like it. Do you really want to play Mark Teahen at 3B all year? You can get Weeks for much cheaper than Davis.

[kidsilk]

Keep Davis here. He is much more valuable than Weeks.