McCann replacement off FA

[uncommonb]

So it looks like McCann's eyes are gonna put him on at least a 15 day DL while he gets Lasik at least. I have narrowed down the available FA for C to: Kurt Suzuki, John Baker, John Buck.

Who do I take and who do Dump to make room for McCann on the DL?
10 team H2H

C - Brian McCann
1B - Miguel Cabrera
2B - Brandon Phillips
3B - Ryan Zimmerman
SS - Derek Jeter
IF - Aubrey Huff
LF - Alfonso Soriano
CF - Vernon Wells
RF - Nate McLouth
OF - Andre Ethier
Util - Hunter Pence
BN - Mike Lowell, Jeremy Hermida, Nick Swisher
DL - Cristian Guzmán

SP - James Shields , Francisco Liriano , Félix Hernández , Brett Myers
RP - Jonathan Papelbon, Carlos Mármol , Justin Masterson
P - Chris Young, Aaron Harang, Scott Baker, Tim Wakefield
DL - , Ricky Romero, Kelvim Escobar
BN - David Price, Jordan Zimmermann

[Trojan Pony]

I was in the same situation and went with Suzuki, but Baker wasn't available. He's not flashy but he's consistent and starts more frequently than a lot of catchers, particularly Buck. Baker has more upside and would probably be a better long-term option, but I like Suzuki better as a fill-in.

[justink15]

i replaced with AJ who i dropped when he came back, and now Aj on waivers so i replaced him with Jesus (the player, not the bible character)

[uncommonb]

"I was in the same situation and went with Suzuki, but Baker wasn't available. He's not flashy but he's consistent and starts more frequently than a lot of catchers, particularly Buck. Baker has more upside and would probably be a better long-term option, but I like Suzuki better as a fill-in."

So I have my options between both of them then....I guess the question is then who should I get rid of on my roster to make room for McCann on DL

[Trojan Pony]

Escobar was just put on the 60-day DL so I'd go ahead and drop him, and then put McCann in his slot.

[schmidty]

Of those guys, I prefer Baker (and that's who I'm picking up for my own McCann disaster)

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=380836