Trade Help ~ Broxton for Hart

[Dimethod]

11 team keeper league, standard scoring.

I have a guy in my league who is really trying to get one of my closers. He has offered me Dye for Fransico or Broxton for David Ortiz

He didn't make the draft so he said he has a few players he isn't attached too.

Would you make the trade?

Broxton for Hart

My Closers are:
Soria
Broxton
Fuentes
Fransico
Ziegler

OF:
Beltran
Pence
Nelson Cruz
Hermida
Rasmus
J. Upton
Snider

[dave knight]

Hart is just about a 20/20 guarantee over the whole season. That is good value for you for a closer.

[Dimethod]

Would you rather trade Frank Francisco (unknown) for Dye or Broxton for Hart?

[MaudDib]

I would keep Broxton. I think Broxton will be one of the best closers and not a big fan of Hart. I would rather do the deal for Dye even though you aren't getting a great player. Though really not a big fan of either offer.

[twistedude]

I like Hart, but Broxton is elite this year. I'd stand pat for now. Thanks for the help with mine.

[jmcampbe11]

I like the Francisco for Dye trade. It's a better value for you. Broxton is one of those unique relievers who can help out in multiple categories (especially Ks).

Can you return the favor plz? viewtopic.php?t=380784

[forrestk]

Yes, I would absolutely do the trade of Francisco for Dye. Even at the age of 35, Dye is a lock for .290, 35 home runs. You gotta do the deal!

[sha]

i'm liking broxton too. i like francisco for dye.

[Dimethod]

Thanks all you guys came thru for me again!

[CubsFan7724]

Take Dye.