Ethier for Cantu ? WHIR

[clarkw267]

I have been offered Cantu straight up for my Ethier. I'm thinking this might be a nice trade for me considering the options I have at 3B. Is this a good deal for me, or should I counter offer?

My Team
12 team roto (5x5) keeper (keep 6)
C - Pierzynski
1B - Pujols
2B - Weeks
3B - Encarnacion
SS - Bartlett
OF - Sizemore
OF - Braun
OF - B Upton
UT - Ethier
BN - D Lee
BN - Ibanez
BN - Wood
DL - Doumit

SP - J Santana
SP - Haren
RP - Rodney
RP - Rivera
P - Myers
P - Porcello
P - W Rodriguez
BN - Lohse
BN - Baker

[bazzy_51]

decline for me... i really like Ethier for this year, he has alot of help around him that will allow good production and your 1B/3B options really aren't that bad, if you are dead set on getting a 3B option i would need more then Cantu to rid of Ethier...

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=380733

[forrestk]

No, do not do this deal. Ethier is much, much better than Cantu and has a nice upside.

[cdawg4343]

Don't do it. I turned down Cantu and Duncan in my league for Ethier. He benefits so much from hitting behind Manny.

[jmcampbe11]

Absolutely not. Ethier is more valuable.

Return the favor plz - viewtopic.php?t=380754

[lbblue]

You could definitely use an upgrade at 3B and you have plenty of talent/depth in your OF. However, I still wouldn't move Ethier for Cantu. If you really want to upgrade your 3B position I'd aim a little higher and put together something else.

viewtopic.php?t=380746

[red wing stud]

I like Cantu but Ethier way more...

Ibanez for Cantu. That's what I'd offer back...or look for a better 3B if you still want to trade Ethier

here's mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=380692

[clarkw267]

Bump... still on the table.

[fierro33]

take it off lol



eithier is alot more valuable than cantu stop thinkin about it


viewtopic.php?t=380996

[clarkw267]

Would Ibanez for Cantu be a good counter offer?