Reyes/Arod trade WHIR

[MotorCityKitties]

12 team league 7x7 Keeper (K's and OPS for batters & Holds and K/BB for pitchers)

C: Yadier
1B: Morneau
2B: Cano
3B: MCab
SS: Theriot
OF: Beltran
OF: Hart
OF: Abreu
OF: Damon
Util: Jacobs
Util: Cruz
Util: Blalock
BN: Wieters
BN: Church
BN: Hideki Matsui
BN: Sandoval
DL: Arod

SP: Peavy
SP: Hamels
SP: Gallardo
RP: Corpas
RP: Qualls
RP: Kuo
P: Wandy Rod
P: Davies
P: Saito
P: Coffey
BN: Street
BN: Chris Perez
BN: McClellan
BN: Baker
DL: E Santana

First let me explain a little bit about the league. There will only be 4 keepers after this season, expanded to 7 after next year. I won the first 2 years of the league and I have a chance to win again this year.

I've been offered:

Jose Reyes/Justin Verlander/Brett Myers


for

Arod/Damon/Jake Peavy

I hate including Peavy, but realistically he wasn't going to be one of my 4 keepers after this season. If this trade went through I would keep MCab, Reyes, Morneau and Beltran. Reyes is 8 years younger than Arod. Does that difference make up for what I'm losing between Verlander/Myers and Peavy/Damon? Please help. I'm torn on this one. Originally I thought no way, but after looking at the difference in age between Reyes and Arod and the uncertainty with Arod's hip/roids I'm starting to think I might want to accept. Please help and as always leave a link and I will help you.

[Darth Danielus]

I say no. arod and reyes are close-ish in value, with arod due back shortly. The dowgrades are too much I think (though I would think about an arod for reyes deal if the rest of it wasn't so significant.)