Which trade should I do?

[bcbhockey68]

Which trade should I do? And which one is the fairest?

My Hamels and Lind for his Holliday and Kershaw
or
My Hamels and Lind for his Mclouth and Kershaw

[forrestk]

Both trades are good deals for you, and it is based strictly on what you need. If you can deal with a slight BA hit, take McLouth and Kershaw. Holliday won't hurt you as much in the BA department, but it will come at a slight sacrifice on home run and steal numbers.

Be careful here: Lind is a prime breakout candidate, and he could continue to hit at a great rate. That being said, I would take McLouth and Kershaw for that duo.

[bcbhockey68]

Here is my roster so you can tell me what I need

C Ramón Hernández (Cin - C)
1B Justin Morneau (Min - 1B)
2B Chase Utley (Phi - 2B)
3B David Wright (NYM - 3B)
SS Felipe López (Ari - 2B,3B,SS,OF)
OF Corey Hart (Mil - OF)
OF Jay Bruce (Cin - OF)
OF Brad Hawpe (Col - OF)
Util Adrián González (SD - 1B)
Util Chris Davis (Tex - 1B,3B)
SP Cole Hamels (Phi - SP)
SP Yovani Gallardo (Mil - SP)
RP José Valverde (Hou - RP)
RP Brian Fuentes (LAA - RP)
P Frank Francisco (Tex - RP)
P Roy Oswalt (Hou - SP)
P Kevin Gregg (ChC - RP)
BN Adam Lind (Tor - OF)
BN Matt Wieters (Bal - C)NA
BN Gil Meche (KC - SP)
BN Max Scherzer (Ari - SP,RP)
BN Ricky Nolasco (Fla - SP)
DL Chris Carpenter (StL - SP)DL

[forrestk]

Top to bottom, your roster is extremely solid. I would look for a slight upgrade at catcher, but hang tight with the rest of this roster.

I would still carry out that trade with McLouth and Kershaw. Hamels is way too much of an investment for him to be having the injury problems he has.

[bcbhockey68]

anyone else think I should do this trade?