Sexy Alexi for Uggla (WHIR)

[Holein1]

Who would you rather have...alexei Ramirez or Uggla in a straight up trade.

[Holein1]

Bump...is it worth it for me to pick up alexei

[bazzy_51]

i like Uggla over Alexei... Uggla may not have a top average but hes got the power to back up the lack there of average and i just don't see Alexei replicating what he did last year... Uggla for me...


help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=380733

[jmcampbe11]

Stick with Alexei. He started slow last year too then heated up. Look at his splits for the month of April in 08 for context.

Return the favor plz - viewtopic.php?t=380754

[red wing stud]

I had an option of getting Alexi or Uggla in a dynasty league...I chose Uggla cuz he's proven and you know what you're getting with him...lots of HR, R's, RBI's, and good Slugging %.

In a seasonal league I would still choose Uggla...I think Ramirez was overblown going into the year. Although he did start out slow last year as well. Even if he gets back into the groove Alexi won't dominate categories like Uggla can.

mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=380692

[twistedude]

I prefer Uggla. Far more proven, a good source of middle infield power, and I'm just not sold on Alexei.

Here's mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=380740