Would you trade Vlad for E. Santana?

[pizzaboy76]

Would you trade Vlad for E. Santana?

My OF is Ethier, Holliday, Pence, and Span(We start 4) and Vlad is on my bench (We only have 4 bench spots and no DL)

My SP is J. Santana, Burnett, Lilly, Volstad, Cahill, J. Sanchez, and Parra. We start 8 Pitchers and can change them daily.

[Howie]

I'd keep Vlad. They're both going to be back around the same time but Vlad is the more valuable player. I doubt Ervin will be as good as he was last year anyways.

[pizzaboy76]

Now 2 options on the table

1. Vlad for E. Santana
2. Vlad for R. Martin

My current Catcher is Napoli. Should I pull the trigger on either?

Howie,

Why are you down on Santana? Do you think his injury will set him back?

[bazzy_51]

i wouldn't do Vlady for Santana as i also think the injury will set Santana down a few pegs from where he was... but i like Vlad for Martin big time anyways... and with Socia not playing Napoli near enough to have significant value thats a huge boost at C... id pull the trigger on Vlady for Martin...

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=380733