Choo or Dukes

[mattyo167]

10 team H2H league.
Cats - Avg.,R,HR,RBI,S / K,W,Whip,ERA,S
Roster -
C Napoli
1b A. Gonzalez
2b Uggla
SS H. Ramirez
3b C. Jones
MI Furcal
CI Huff
OF Kemp
OF Ibanez
OF Dye
OF B.J. Upton
OF Rios
Util Cantu
Be Choo
Be Dukes
SP Halladay
SP Lester
SP Meche
SP K. Davies
SP Nolasco
RP H. Bell
RP Valverde
RP Rodney
RP R. Franklin
Be D. Price

Ok, so I'm happy to carry Cantu as Chipper Jones insurance. And I think Choo and Dukes are both decent bench options. But with Uggla struggling right now, and my hesitance to drop him prematurely, I'd like to add Aaron Hill in place of one of them. Should I just sit tight with Uggla as my only 2b option and keep both Choo and Dukes? Or if it's worth picking up Hill, which one should I drop? Thanks. (Freddy Sanchez and Asdrubal Cabrera are both also available as FA).

[h2wm]

If you feel good about your stolen base position right now, I'd drop Elijah Dukes and pick up someone. If you think you need to keep the steals, I'd drop Choo.

I rank the guys as follows:
Asdrubal Cabrera
Freddy Sanchez
Aaron Hill

But to be honest, I'd go with who you think is going to do best. I think those three plays are all pretty similar. Stick with Uggla though. He isn't that much fun to start all the time. But he is worth it in the long run.