Dynasty Triple Sport Trade...Gallardo Key Piece. WHIR!!

[red wing stud]

Dynasty 8 team League (keep players forever). We have extra bench spots to make up for the shallowness of the league. Free Agency is thinner then you'd think.

It's a Triple Sport League and baseball is the final sport for the overall championship. So far me and one other guy have met in every championship game and only 1 overall standing point separates us.

I WANT THE TROPHY!!!

here's the offer: (rookies are protected for 3 years and after that time you can choose one guy to "franchise" and the others you must either cut or put on your active roster)

I give: Buster Posey, Matt Gamel, and my 1.7 NFL rookie draft pick

I get: Yovani Gallardo

My team is listed in my signature...Giving up to much for a run at this years title? (we get a huge trophy & $140 for winning it)

[red wing stud]

Here's my team seeing as the signature didnt' show up
Dynasty League:
C: Maeur
1B: Pujols
2B: Uggla/Ian Stewart
3B: Chipper/AlexGordon
SS: Tulo/SDrew
OF's: Sizemore, Braun, Ellsbury, Bay
P's: Felix, Bedard, Liriano, Slowey, CC, Harden, Kershaw,DiceK,
CP's: Lidge, FFrancisco, Wood
Protected Rookies: Colby Rasmus, Matt GAmel, McCutchen, Buster Posey, AEscobar, Moustakas, Laporta

[JoeJoe41189]

I would make this trade. The goal of keeper leagues is to win NOW and build for the future. Your team is already pretty good where you can compete without those 2 pitchers and the NFL draft class doesn't look to impressive by the time you'd be picking 7th. I would try to get someone maybe a little better then Gallardo but I would make this trade if I couldn't get anyone else. And besides you want the trophy NOW.

[billycent]

I don't know a whole lot about dynasty, especially 3 sport... sounds fun though. Also I'm not sure I understand which nfl rookie draft pick u give up (1.7) is that 1st rd. and 7th rd.? All that being said though, I say Gallardo is a fantastic pitcher and at 23 looks to be a valuable piece to your team for years to come. I'd say go for it. Thnx for the help on mine.

p.s. I get it 1st rd 7th pick. duh!

[Cypher74]

I do like Gallardo and I think you have enough young talent to withstand the loss. I never like giving up a first round pick, but I guess that depends how many you keep in the NFL league.

I'd probably do this deal and take home the trophy!

Thanks for the help!

[red wing stud]

Bump...and if anyone is interested in learning about a 3 sport dynasty league let me know. I'll share the insights about it.

[dave knight]

I'd do the deal. I like Gallardo enough and it's not like Gamel and Posey are monumental players; Posey seems to be a decent hitting, very good defense catcher; from what I've read he's no Wieters

viewtopic.php?t=380767

[sha]

i'd be lying if i told you i was familiar with this type of league, but it seems to me that you are trading away future in the nfl side of things (it's only a rookie selection, though) ann increasing your chances of winning now. Gallardo could be the peice you need to provide you another chamoionship...seems to make sense to me, but i must admit this format is a bit over my head, good luck! thanks for the help!

[AshesOfEmpires]

A one sport dynasty I can do...three though? Might have to try that someday. As for this deal, I would do it. Helps you win now and the NFL Class of 09 isn't that strong imo.

[clarkw267]

I would do this deal. Gallardo is a good young SP and what you're giving up isn't anything crazy.