Gardner's value in AL only league WHIR

[rentz]

I have Gardner as a bench CF in a 9 team al only keeper.
An offer has been made to be Aardsma for Gardner.

I'm conflicted because I really feel if gardner gets consistent starts he will give a decent avg and 30sbs.... BUT
Aardsma gives me a nice handcuff for morrow. I had aardsma at the start of the season but dropped him when morrow got named.

My Team:

C Jason Varitek C
1B Aubrey Huff 1B, 3B, DH
2B Dustin Pedroia 2B
3B Chris Davis 1B, 3B
SS Mike Aviles 2B, SS
LF Pat Burrell LF
CF Grady Sizemore CF
RF Bobby Abreu RF
UTIL Jack Cust LF, DH
Bench J.D. Drew RF
Bench Asdrubal Cabrera 2B, SS
Bench Brett Gardner CF
Bench Russell Branyan 3B
Bench C Jeff Clement C, DH

P Felix Hernandez
P Jon Lester
P Brian Fuentes
P Brandon Morrow
P Gavin Floyd
P Joe Saunders
P Derek Holland
Bench Clay Buchholz

[JoeJoe41189]

Although I'm not sold on Gardner I wouldn't make this trade. Your team is slow and he provides a nice burst of speed.

[METS 24]

Deleted

[ab]

I don't think I would do this. Gardner isn't great, but there is some value there. I understand the value of handcuffs in AL/NL-onlys, but that just isn't enough.

PS Thanks for the help on mine.