I was offered Matt Holliday for George Sherrill

[MadDog36]

Total insanity. That is veto-worthy. Now if that were Krod/Nathan something like that, you'd have cause for argument.

You accept that deal and run away a winner.

Do you mind posting some FAs in your league?

[quitesanemax]

Well we will see if it gets vetoed, although nothing ever gets vetoed in this league, and there have been some bad ones over the years. I don't think this is as incredibly bad as people are making it out to be... although I agree that I have to accept it. This guy clearly doesn't believe that Holliday is any good outside of Coors. I'm also a little worried that I won't see much return on this. But for Sherrill, how could I not do this trade. He really should have tried for more for him.

Theres really not that much available on waivers. I'll have to wait til later to do that. I can't do it here at work.

Thanks for the advice! I knew I had to accept the trade, I just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing something about Holliday that I hadn't heard. Also, on an offer like that I like to give it a day to give him the chance to change his mind. He had over a day, and he didn't, so I accepted it.

Max

[angels7777]

I don't think this is as incredibly bad as people are making it out to be

it's definitely as bad as we are saying - Sherill is a shaky closer and may lose his job to Ray at some point this year - Holliday may not put up Coors numbers, but he did not exactly just lose all his skills overnight either.... make the deal and hope it doesn't get vetoed, but I have 2 questions:

1) Is this a money league?
2) If it is, do you have an extra opening next year for me ?

[Sid Bream's Slide]

I don't think this is as incredibly bad as people are making it out to be.

Oh it absolutely is as bad, if not worse.