I was offered Matt Holliday for George Sherrill

[quitesanemax]

This seems like a no-brainer... yet I have my questions about Holliday. Was it Coors field that makes him good? Also, I am down to only two official closers... this would bring me down to one.

Here is our league format:
H2H 12 team nonkeeper - 26 player roster w/ 2 DL.
Pitching: W,L,SV,K,Hld,ERA,WHIP
Batting: R,HR,RBI,SB,FPCT,AVG,OBP
Pitchers used: SP,SP,RP,RP,P,P,P,P
30 innings pitched minimum

Here is what my team looks like presently:

C: AJ Pierzynski (CWS - C)
1B:M. Cabrera (Det - 1B,3B)
2B: K. Johnson Atl-2B)
3B: C. Davis (Tex 1B,3B)
SS: Felipe Lopez (Ari - 2B,3B,SS,LF)
IF: C. Guillen (Det - 1B,3B,LF)
LF: C. Quentin (CWS - LF)
CF: C. Beltran (NYM - CF)
RF: J. Kubel(Min - LF,RF)
OF: S. Victorino (Phi - CF)
Util: H. Matsui (NYY - LF)

Bench: M. Weiters (Bal - C), O. Cabrera(Oak - SS), T. Tulowitski(Col-SS), J. Francoeur (Atl-RF),
DL: V. Guerrero (LAA - RF)

SP: A. Wainwright (StL), B. Myers (Phi), D. Lowe (Atl),G. Meche (KC)

RP: G. Sherrill (Bal), J. Broxton (LAD), O.Dotel(CWS), R. Soriano(Atl), T. Coffey(Mil),H. Okajima(Bos)
SP/RP: D. Meyer(Fla)
DL: J. Lackey(LAA)

[Mudville]

I absolutely take that trade!!! Hell, you can flip Holliday for a top closer if you don't want to keep him.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=380582

[Howie]

Just click accept and stop overthinking it.

[HOOTIE]

Just click accept and stop overthinking it.

[wkpdpack]

I'd make that deal without even debating. There will be plenty of closers you can add. Right now you could go get Downs. I wouldn't be surprised if he holds down the job for awhile.


Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=380601

[TheNephilim]

I'd make that deal if even if holliday woke up tomorrow with no arms or legs.

[angels7777]

I'd make that deal if even if holliday woke up tomorrow with no arms or legs.

- please refrain from polluting these messageboards with these types of no-brainers!!!!

[Sid Bream's Slide]

asdfl;fasd

[CrazedGoat]

no offense, but a post like this should be in the beginners section...

[jakesnake48]

Wow....I offered M. Cain for Holliday and the owner rejected my offer. You wanna swap leagues??