BIG TIME TRADE! Whir

[captain num nuts]

Holliday, Lowe and Aviles for Sizemore and Brandon Phillips. Who wins? WHIR

[WyldStallyn]

i'd prefer sizemore/philips, so long as the team has some high average guys

[Hit Factory]

The guy who got Sizemore/Phillips won. As I said from the moment he was traded to Oakland, Matt Holliday will not put up numbers close to what he did at Coors. Derek Lowe is decent, certainly not an ace, and Aviles is a huge question mark...sophomore slump? Sizemore is awesome and will give you homers, runs and steals, while Phillips has started off slowly but is a solid proven hitter and should put up good numbers.