Need Help Guys . . . Trade for which OF?

[Neboguy]

Alright, need your help on this one guys . . . This guy just updated his trading block. He says he will give up a lot for pitching . . . I am dead last in pitching in the league(2nd in Batting), but feel the urge to take advantage of the situation and pounce . . . as I need another OF. Delmon Young is not cutting it and I'm sticking to my LIMA plan as SP's can be had all season.

Here is my team.
13 Team Non-Keeper League (Re-Draft)

Nu Merically Whipped

C-John Buck
C-Jorge Posada
1B-Billy Butler
2B-Ian Kinsler
SS-Rafael Furcal
3B-Aramis Ramirez
MI-Felipe Lopez
CL-Kevin Kouzmanoff
OF-Carlos Lee
OF-Torii Hunter
OF-Andre Ethier
OF-Hunter Pence
OF-Delmon Young
DH-David Ortiz
P-Francisco Liriano
P-Clayton Kershaw
P-Joba Chamberlain
P-Johnny Cueto
P-Kenshin Kawakami
P-Koji Uejara
P-Frank Francisco
P-Chris Perez
P-Manny Corpas

Bench
C-Matt Wieters
P-Ubalbo Jiminez
2B-Akinori Iwamura
SS-Elvis Andrus
OF-Micah Hoffpauir

DL
Joey Devine

Here is his team.

Napoli, Mike C ANA
Snyder, Chris C ARI
Pujols, Albert 1B STL
Lopez, Jose 2B SEA
Fields, Josh D. 3B CHW
Jeter, Derek SS NYY
Bartlett, Jason SS TB
Blake, Casey 3B LA
Duncan, Chris 1B STL
Dunn, Adam LF WAS
Granderson, Curtis CF DET
Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA
Swisher, Nick CF NYY
Hafner, Travis DH CLE

Active Pitchers
Carmona, Fausto SP CLE
Halladay, Roy SP TOR
Jenks, Bobby RP CHW
McCarthy, Brandon SP TEX
Millwood, Kevin SP TEX
Price, David SP TB
Sabathia, CC SP NYY
Wang, Chien-Ming SP NYY
Ziegler, Brad RP OAK

Reserve Batters
Stewart, Ian 3B COL
Guzman, Cristian SS WAS
Blalock, Hank 1B TEX
Francoeur, Jeff RF ATL

Reserve Pitchers
Lee, Cliff SP CLE


I'm thinking about offering him Francisco Liriano for Dunn, Granderson, Ichiro, or Swisher. What would you guys recommend?

[bossoaks]

I would go with Ichiro at this point. You know he is going to produce for you and you don't have to worry about when the other guys gets off the DL...i.e. Swisher.

[Hit Factory]

Hey there, thanks for the help with mine! I like the idea of trading Liriano, I don't particularly like him but I think he is a big name guy and if the other is desperate for SP he will be happy to have him. I would go for Adam Dunn and use him at first base, Billy Butler isn't hitting anything right now and Dunn is a lock for 40 homers. Your outfield is really good, even with Delmon not producing. The good thing is that if Butler starts to hit you can then just bench Delmon and throw Dunn into your outfield.

[plapre3]

What are your Stat Cats? If this league counts OBP or OPS then Swisher and Dunn get a nice bump in value and of course, Ichiro's declines.

Still, I like the idea... I'd probably go with Dunn if those cats count

[Neboguy]

5X5 R, HR, RBI, AVG, SB

[Grizzlies]

I think I'd go for Dunn first, Ichiro second and Swisher third (if he doesn't go for Dunn).

thanks for the help on mine

[petert]

your team is very close to mine and i like it alot.

If you want power got to go with Dunn.

Other then Dunn not much on the other guys "hitting" team that i like. (well except for puljos).
I would try to trade off Joba or Keshaw for Dunn. I think Kershaw will come down to earth very soon and i think joba is over rated as a starter.

Also the other poster said Liriano for Dunn. I think Liriiano is your ace. And although you may have to do this to get dunn but i would disagree with the other poster. I think lirino is going to be real good as soon as the twinkies start paying better ball. They always end up being the hottest team down the stretch.
good luck.

[Neboguy]

Well I offered him 3 trades

Liriano for Dunn
Liriano for Granderson
Liriano for Ichiro

I'm going to let these hang out there for a couple hours, if he doesn't accept, I'm pulling them back . . .