What SP do I pickup for the best value without taking 4ever?

[bengbrewer]

What SP do I pickup for the best value throughout the season without taking 4ever to produce? WHIR
Its a H2H league.

Carpenter
Hansen
Price
Zimmermann
Hughes

[trevizzle]

carp-injury prone. he's done.
hansen- still in the minors, not touted as much as price or zimmermann.
price- a lot of pressure to succeed, has electric stuff, but i think it's too much pressure.
zimmermann- didn't wow the minors like price did, but was still electric, and has no pressure to win...as the nats are total crap
hughes- no. he's had enough time.

i go zimmermann.

[MadDog36]

Zimm compares to all the pitchers on this list and he's up in the majors and I doubt he'll get sent down. He'll probably move up a spot or two in the rotation before the end of the season. Just remember he'll provide you plenty of upside for the first 3/4 of the season, but be prepared for the playoff push.

I'm assuming this isn't a keeper b/c of all these priceless (no pun) FAs you posted.

Can you post your roster please.

If it is.....you are in hog heaven. (I'd probably find a more competitive league)

[Yanks_Baby]

Pick up Zimmerman until Price gets the call up. Anyone suggesting that Price and Zimmermasn are even close to comparable has no idea what they're talking about. Zimmerman's ceiling is a #2 pitcher, and will muvh more likely be a solid #3. Price has the stuff to be the next lincecum.

Overall

Price




Hanson
Zimmerman
Hughes


But grab Zimmerman since he's starting and wait until Price gets his eventual call up.

[bossoaks]

My vote would be Zimmerman, but I really like Carp. If he comes off DL healthy (non pitching injury) he should be a pretty good starter.

[auclairkeithbc]

Price. It won't take all that long for him to get called up.

[Sid Bream's Slide]

Zimmermann

The drop him for Hanson when he's called up

Maybe drop him for Price when he's called up (unless he's straight dealing)