His Nathan for my Mauer?

[Therobsclub]

I only have 2 closers. Heath Bell and Manuel Corpas.

The Catcher I have in currently is Mike Napoli. Looking to pick up Doumit since he was just put on the Waivers today.

I think I should do the deal. Only thing Average Joe is good for is Average.

[briane]

Doumit is out 8-10 weeks.

I would stick with Mauer.

[Therobsclub]

I know. Here is my full lineup:

C: Napoli
1b: Berkman
2b: Kendrick
SS: Hanley
3b: Zimmerman
IF: Cano
OF: Soriano
OF: McClouth
OF: Ichiro
Util: Jason Bay
BN: Dukes
DL: Mauer

SP: Beckett
SP: Verlander
SP: Perez
RP: Bell
RP: Corpas
P: Meyers
P: Meche
P: Rodney (Forgot I had him)
Bn: Sanchez
BN: Lohse
BN: Matsuzaka
BN: Price

[cnote23]

I would have to say yes even though Napoli is still just sharing time at the plate he still can give you 20 or more homers.

[Therobsclub]

Bump! WHIR!

[abstractpoet]

What is your league format? In any case, I would most likely pull the trigger on this one. Nathan is an elite closer; Mauer is a good hitter, but the difference between him and Napoli is not likely to be as great as indicated by their respective draft positions. And Napoli should get at least a few more DH at bats with Vlad being out.

Here's mine:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=380397

[Therobsclub]

League format is:

HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OBP, Cycle, Slam

Wins, CG, Saves, ERA, WHIP, No Hitter

Should I do this?

[dagactor]

I'd do it. Nathan is solid and Mauer hits for avg, but whatever.