Ethier for Gavin Floyd?

[hooperbrave]

H2H 10 Team - 5 player keeper league
Pitching and batting points fairly even
26 roster limit with 2 roster slots for Injuries
C Posada/Mauer on DL Roster
1B Teixeira/ C. Jackson
2B Roberts/Weeks
3B Wright/Rolen/A. Gordon
SS Furcal/O. Cabrera
OF Quentin/Abreu/Ellsbury/Ethier/Swisher/V. Wells
DH Giambi
SP Lee/Hamels/Arroyo/Dempster/Harang/Duke/Slowey/Garland
RP Fuentes/Marmol

After reading what should be included in my post for advice I added the above to my roster profile. I am in need of SP and the other is need of OF. I have been offered Ethier for Gavin Floyd but counter offered Swisher for Gavin as well as added Ellsbury for Ted Lilly. Any suggestions on the fairest trade?

[flloyd]

I think you should be able to get more for Ethier than Danks. Danks is simply performing over his true skills and he's bound to come down. Also do not do Ellsbury for Lilly. Ellsbury is MUCH more valuable than Lilly.

[cdawg4343]

Don't trade Ethier, he will be good the entire year. Also don't trade Ellisbury. I would deal Swisher while he's hot.

help me out?
viewtopic.php?t=380707