Give up Josh Hamilton for Lincecum?

[FBBVirgin]

I have a sick outfield, so Hamilton can be expendable. Do I make this trade???

C- Doumit (Teagarden while doumit is on DL)
C- Synder
1B- Morneau
2B- Kinsler
SS- Felipe Lopez
3B- Chris Davis
MI- Aaron Hill
CI- Loney
OF- Hamilton
OF- Kemp
OF- Victorino
OF- McClouth
OF- Maybin
UT- O dogg


P-Liriano
P- Joba
P- Gallardo
P-Velander
P- Gonzales
P- Frank Fransisco
P- Hanrahan
P- Meche
P- Ubaldo Jimenez


WHIR thanks

[baseballfreak3135]

What kind of league? Generally I'd say no, Hamilton is too good for Lincecum, but it depends somewhat on your league.

[Howie]

Your OF is good but you're still starting Cameron Maybin. If you lose Hammy then your OF gets a whole lot thinner. I'd hang onto Hamilton.

Help?

viewtopic.php?t=380261

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd stick with Hamilton and wait on your current pitching staff, which is pretty decent.

[MsFan24]

Another vote to keep Hamilton. If you're starting Maybin, you must be pretty thin, even though you have some definite studs at the top of your OF. You have a decent rotation, no need to reach for Lincecum.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=380178

[thejusman1]

Gotta keep Hamilton. See if he'll do it for Kemp + Ubaldo or something.

Help on mine? viewtopic.php?t=380262

[dubstar]

your outfield is good, but not sick. you lose a ton of power if you lose hamilton. im not too big on mclouth myself, and maybin will have some serioius struggles i think.

i wouldnt do it.

[Guzman24]

Nope. Dont like the deal. Keep Hamilton. Question marks surrounding Maybin,McClouth and Victorino. Your OF isn't as deep as you think it is.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=380233

[davdav]

If it is still open, DO IT!!! haha.

Mine:

[Hit Factory]

I think you have a really solid outfield even without Hamilton.....Kemp-McClouth-Victorino is pretty nasty. Hamilton is slightly injured and who knows if he will repeat last years performance? You could really use an ace like Lincecum, so I would make the deal. Your other option is to deal McClouth straight up for a lesser SP who will still help your staff, such as Josh Johnson, Danks, Wainwright, or Bedard. Either way I think trading one of your outfielders for a SP is a good move