Beckett and Mclouth for Hamels?

[bcbhockey68]

Fair or not?

[Hit Factory]

Um no lol. I have Hamels on my team, the guy is still working out the kinks but who knows what the lingering effects from his injury will be? Beckett will probably have a similar year to Hamels, if not better and McClouth is a really good hitter. So whoever gets Hamels is getting screwed.

[TheRaven]

Um no lol. I have Hamels on my team, the guy is still working out the kinks but who knows what the lingering effects from his injury will be? Beckett will probably have a similar year to Hamels, if not better and McClouth is a really good hitter. So whoever gets Hamels is getting screwed.

Agreed.

[Eightan]

Bad deal.

[bcbhockey68]

I'm the Hamels owner so what if I added either Lind, Bruce, or Hawpe to the trade?

[Hit Factory]

If you added Lind or Hawpe it would make it much more fair, Bruce has to show some signs of life first.

[mak1277]

I'm the Hamels owner so what if I added either Lind, Bruce, or Hawpe to the trade?

I have a team with Beckett/McLouth. I can't imagine agreeing to a trade like that even if you included any of those three OFs. I think McLouth is better than all of them, and I like Beckett to be equal to (or better than) Hamels this year.

[aarongzmn]

I would actually do this. It really depends on your team. How is your offense? McLouth is good for a 20+/20+ season. Beckett is not as good as Hamels but will provide the same # of K's.

I drafted McLouth this season and just traded him for Ortiz. I dont know how that is gonna turn out.

[bcbhockey68]

My Team:
C Ramón Hernández
1B Justin Morneau
2B Chase Utley
3B David Wright
SS Felipe Lopez
OF Corey Hart
OF Brad Hawpe
OF Jay Bruce
Util Adrián González
Util Chris Davis
BN Matt Wieters
BN Adam Lind

SP Cole Hamels
SP Roy Oswalt
RP José Valverde
RP Brian Fuentes
P Yovani Gallardo
P Kevin Gregg
P Frank Francisco
BN Gil Meche
BN Max Scherzer
BN Ricky Nolasco
DL Chris Carpenter

[afern401]

Not knowing anything about the teams or league makes it more difficult but I still wouldnt pull the trigger if I had Beckett and Mclouth. Beckett is comparable to Hamels in enough categories that I dont see the advantage in this trade.