Trader Question about M. Young

[Rassixx]

Trying to aquire Michael Young. Do you guys thing im offering too much or to little?

Thinking of offering
Carlos Delgado and Rafael Furcal
for
Michael Young and Armando Galaraga

If not what other combination do you think i could go with, I want to plug Young in as my 3B
Rosters below.

CBS 10 teams h2h.
My Roster
C-Inge, Brandon
1B-Howard, Ryan
3B-Cano, Robinson
3B-Encarnacion, Edwin
SS-Furcal, Rafael
OF-Abreu, Bobby RF
OF-Markakis, Nick
OF-McLouth, Nate
U-Cabrera, Miguel

Active Pitchers
SP-Cain, Matt SP
SP-Greinke, Zack
SP-Harang, Aaron
SP-Millwood, Kevin
SP-Weaver, Jered
RP-Bell, Heath
RP-Wood, Kerry

Reserves
Berkman, Lance
Delgado, Carlos
Drew, Stephen
Rios, Alex
Jimenez, Ubaldo

His Roster:

C-Doumit, Ryan
1B-Votto, Joey
2B-Roberts, Brian
3B-Zimmerman, Ryan
SS-Young, Michael
OF-Bay, Jason
OF-Beltran, Carlos
OF-Ethier, Andre
U-Suzuki, Ichiro
Active Pitchers
SP-Bedard, Erik
SP-Billingsley, Chad
SP-Galarraga, Armando
SP-Halladay, Roy
SP-Santana, Johan
RP-Reyes, Anthony
RP-Uehara, Koji

Reserves
Blake, Casey
Crawford, Carl
Ordonez, Magglio
Danks, John
Meche, Gil

[jackie hayes]

Cabrera isn't 3b-eligible, then?

Based on adp, you'd be giving up too much, but that's skewed because Young and Galarraga have played well (Galarraga, in particular, would be drafted much higher today). So I wouldn't say it's wildly off, but I'd still start lower. Maybe just offer Furcal and Millwood, see if he bites (probably won't, but worth a shot).

I'm not sure about the trade, though. You don't have many steals, but you're trading away one of your only steals guys, and you want to trade him to a team that already has a ton of steals. Plus Delgado would only be a bench player for him, as well. Just doesn't seem to be a good fit.

[MadDog36]

I'd just keep: Carlos Delgado and Rafael Furcal. You don't need Young with owning Furcal already.

[Rassixx]

Im trying to get better at 3B since Young is eligible at 3B. Since i still have M. Cab, Howard and Berkam for 1B i can part with Delgado. Also i have Drew to play SS and i would also have Young since he is also SS eligible.

[MadDog36]

If you want to upgrade at 3b. Deal one of those 1b for a 3b. That will work better.

[JediMaster]

See if Ian Stewart's available either as a free agent or whoever has him, he'll bring above average power production with a lower pricetag than alot of other options at 3rd. However, if you're looking to trade with this particular person, go after Zimmerman over Young.