His Cantu or Galarraga for my Matt Capps? WHIR!!

[devastor]

I am in a 12 team points only league. Guy wants my Matt Capps for his A. Galarraga. I need SP and 3rd. Thinking of counter his Cantu for my Matt Capps. What do yall think?

HIS TEAMC - Molina
1st - Pena
2nd - A. Hill
3rd - Wright
SS - Aviles
OF - C. Lee, Hunter, Damon
Util - Cantu, Alex. Ramirez
BN - Pence, Span Wieters

SP - Linecum, D. Haren, Oswalt
RP - Lidge, M. Gonzalez
P - Galarraga, Gregg, Meche
BN - Motte

Thanks guys, leave a link.

MY TEAM
12-team points only league:
C: J. Posada
1st:J. Morneau
2nd: B. Roberts
3rd: E. Bonifacio (2B,3B)
SS: S. Drew
OF: R. Braun, B. Abreu, A. Rios
Util:R. Ibanez (OF), N. Swisher (1B, OF)
BN: M. Cameron (OF), M. Bradley (OF), A. Beltre (3B)

SP: J. Beckett, C. Sabathia, B. Myers
RP: J. Nathan, H. Bell
P: M. Capps (RP), G. Sherrill (RP), R. Franklin (RP)
BN: M. Buehrle (SP)
DL: D. Matsuzka (SP), K. Escobar (SP

[Da Rook]

I think I would rather the hitter. Other SP wil come along...so I would go for Cantu. However, is ther a second guy you can include to get both?

Please help me: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379848

[kidsilk]

I would want Cantu for Capps, I don't think Galarraga is that great.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=379640

[devastor]

thanks guys. I am leaning towards that. Anyone else have an idea?

[schmidty]

Capps for Galarraga isn't really good IMO. Capps is really an underrated closer. Yeah, he doesn't get the opportunities other guys get. But he gives you rock solid ratios and has a stranglehold on the closer job. Now Cantu would be pretty good, and would fill the weakest spot in your lineup.

Help in return? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379915

[baseballfreak3135]

Neither. Capps is better than most. K's not fantastic, but ERA and WHIP are solid.

Help in return please:

viewtopic.php?t=379918

[HOOTIE]

Neither. Capps is better than most. K's not fantastic, but ERA and WHIP are solid.

Beltre will do as good as Cantu anyways.

Help in return please:

viewtopic.php?t=379918