Trade Longoria in a keeper?

[BSbludolf]

first year 10-team 3-player keeper league.

I lose- Evan Longoria, Matt Kemp, Dan Uggla, and Roy Halladay
I get- Grady Sizemore, Johan Santana, and Brian McCann

Ian Stewart and either Beltre or Lowell are available on the ww for me to pick up to replace Longoria and Uggla. Do I do this deal in a keeper.

H/AB R H HR RBI SB BB K TB AVG
C Chris Iannetta
1B Albert Pujols
2B Dan Uggla
3B Evan Longoria
SS Jhonny Peralta
IF Chipper Jones
LF Elijah Dukes
CF Willy Taveras
RF Matt Kemp
OF Nelson Cruz
Util Joey Votto
Util B.J. Upton
BN Álex Ríos

W L CG SHO SV K ERA WHIP K/9
SP Matt Cain
SP Roy Halladay
RP Joakim Soria
RP Chad Qualls
P Brandon Morrow
P Fernando Rodney
P Ryan Franklin
BN Yovani Gallardo
BN Zack Greinke
BN Chris Volstad
BN Wandy Rodríguez

[auclairkeithbc]

I'd say definitely do not do this deal. I don't really think Sizemore is an upgrade over Longoria as a keeper, maybe a little upgrade for this year, but maybe not. Santana is an upgrade over Halladay, but mainly just in the Ks department. Halladay is pretty solid. Kemp was predicted by many to be awesome, and he has been so far this season. He is a much better keeper than McCann. I think if that was the deal, without Uggla included, I'd still rather stick with what you've got. But since you'd be just throwing in Uggla, that makes it a clearly bad deal for you. Not to mention those replacement players aren't so hot for a 10 teamer, and you'd be benching Ianetta, who will be just fine this year.

[oddmanout7]

I would stay put, you are giving up too much.

[The Mighty Trow]

yup, you have the upper hand here. he should show you a lot more for what he's asking.