Who is more Valuable in trade..Kinsler, roberts and more

[plainyogurt]

I was offered Crawford, Andrew jones, and rolen for my Berkman, Vallineuava, and Cruz...(i am declining)....The manager is talking about how valuable(stats, and where drafted) each player needs to be....This is what I figured....I need SB's, Runs, and SP....As it is he wants Berkman, and Villenuava(he could have him)... I want Vasquez and either Kinsler, Roberts, Crawford....Who is more Valuable..

I would offer My Berkman(2nd Round), O. Cabrera, and Villenuava

FOr

Kinsler(2nd round), Roberts(4th round) or Crawford(5th ROund), and Vasquez(12)

Would it still be good if i need to add Tulo or Hill instead of cabrera??
Here is my roster(updated with last second WW pickups for today)

5x5 standard league.

SP: Matsusaka, Wainwright, Kershaw, Lilly, Escobar,Pettite*, Zimmerman*
Rp: Valverde, Fuentes, F Cordero,Corpas, Villenuava
C: Y molina
1st: Miguel Cabrera
2nd: Hill
3rd: Youkilis
SS:Tulowitzki
MI:Orlando Cabrera
CI:Berkman
Util: Fielder
Of: Elsbury, Dunn, nelson Cruz, Carlos Gomez, SPan

Bench: Laroche ,Duncan. Alexie Ramirez, Vladdy

[1010011010]

I would offer Hill instead of Cabrera if you are getting Roberts or Kinsler.

[plainyogurt]

anything else?

[Rbsurf]

cabrera off to slow start. hopefully picks it up. Vasquez would fit nice and you wont have to trade another big hitter to get a solid SP..

Try to get kinsler, but roberts will might get more SB's...but kinsler also had 100 less at bats..

[schmidty]

Kinsler is easily the most valuable guy in that group. I do think you need to sweeten the deal to get him. Even though Kinsler and Berkman went around the same in the drafts, Kinsler's been so great that it's going to take a lot to get him - I think you'd need to throw in Tulo to have a shot.

If I were trading Berkman for Roberts, I'd try to get a better SP (instead of Vazquez).

[Leesville Sluggers]

Definately have to sweeten the deal to get kinsler...the way he is playing right now, it may cost you an arm and a leg to get him. I agree with the last post, i would try to get a little bit better SP than vazquez if you are giving up berkman.

[SonsofSlam04]

I believe Kinsler is your most valuable player out of those 3 ,,...as for trading Berkman ,,, only trade him for a stud SP ... Vazquez is not a stud...


Please answer my post

[plainyogurt]

I hear ya...

I am actually thinking of trading for Vmart..I currently been doing waiver Catchers..

Is Berkman for Vmart and Dempster or Bedard fair?
or instead of berk. deal prince?