2 Big Trade offers....WHIR

[casem2k2]

In a 10 team 5x5 roto league.....r,hr,rbi,sb,avg

Which Trade should I do? or should I stay put an not do either???

I trade: johan Santana/Mark Derosa for Manny Ramirez/Carlos Zambrano

or

I trade: Josh Hamilton/Mark Derosa for Carl Crawford/Joba Chamberlain (I am last in sb's)

My lineup:
c pierzynski
c olivo (until wieters is called up)
1b A.gonzalez
2b derosa
3b cantu
ss hanley
ci pujols
mi k.johnson
of holliday
of hamilton
of hart
of c.young
util ortiz
util polanco
b f.lewis, jacobs, wieters, gomez, gardner

sp j.santana
sp lilly
sp billingsley
sp verlander
rp valverde
rp fuentes
p percival
p r.franklin
p saunders
b buehrle, jered weaver
DL e.santana
DL Devine

[oldmanbean]

Personally I would not do either. Santana and Hamilton are untouchables in my book at least.

[casem2k2]

anymore help please

[plainyogurt]

Wouldnt do that..Johan is the man..Joba does not compare..

If you are short on Sb's: deal #1 does not make sense...

If you were going to trade Johan, Hanley or Jose has to be who you target

Help me out please

viewtopic.php?t=379723

[bmmac27]

Agree with the above -

Deal #1 - if Santana is involved then Reyes or H Ram has to be in the mix - don't sell yourself short.
Deal #2 - personally think Joba is a bum I think you're selling Hamilton too low - he's off to a slow start but I think he'll come around