Help me with two trades please(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

First trade is in a AL only league, 10 teams, 30 man rosters(really deep), keeper league, 6x6 roto style (hits and holds as well)

I have been offered: Grady Sizemore, Howie Kendrick, and Cliff Lee for my Ian Kinsler, Nelson Cruz, and Brandon Morrow.

My Team:

C-Teagarden
C-Buck
1B-Overbay
2B-Kinsler
SS-Lillibridge
3B-Figgins
CI-Aybar
MI-Casilla
OF-Cruz
OF-Choo
OF-Sweeney
OF-Scott
OF-Gardner
UTI-Thome
BN-M. Brown
BN-A. Jackson

SP-Contreras
SP-Padilla
SP-DIce K
SP-Ponson
RP-Morrow
RP-Jenks
RP-Kelley
P-ANderson
P-Braden
BN-Lackey
BN-Duscherer
BN-Price


The second deal is HIS Vlad and Billingsley for my Dexter Fowler and Dan Haren. This is in a 15 team, 5 player keeper, 5x5 roto style mixed league and my team is as follows:

Third deal is in this same league....HIS Paul Konerko, Ben Francisco, and Travis Ishikawa for my Carlos Pena. What do you think guys? Should I do any of these deals?

C-Navarro
1B-Pena
2B-J.Lopez
3B-Huff
SS-Theriot
CI-Lowell
MI-Bartlett
OF-McLouth
OF-Pence
OF-Ordonez
UTI-Thome
BN-Swisher
BN-Bourn
BN-Cuddyer

SP-Haren
SP-Harden
SP-Arroyo
RP-Gonzalez
RP-Percival
P-Wainwright
P-Maholm
BN-J. Sanchez
BN-SHeets
BN-Lannan
DL-E. Santana

[woowoo crew]

i wouldn't do any of these deals. kinsler is more valuable than what you'd get in the first deal, even with sizemore thrown in. i just couldn't give up kinsler this year. now, the 2nd deal is worth considering. billingsley is going to be one of the top 5 pitchers this year likely, and he's on a good team. however, vlad is on the DL right? i'd check on that injury before doing the deal.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=94&t=379635

[kidsilk]

anyone else help me out? Leave a link. Thanks

[kidsilk]

bump

[Carnac]

Absolutely not on trade #1.

Second trade. Looks like Vlad will be out for about a month. I would do the deal.
Billingsly will get more run support than Haren. Vlad>Fowler.

good luck

thanks for help with mine

[henketime]

I agree with the people above me. Kinsler is more valuable than Sizemore, nevermind Kinsler AND Nelson Cruz. And Cliff Lee is proving that last year was somewhat of a fluke.

Again, I would also do the second deal. Billingsley is turning out to be a stud and Vlad is just icing on the cake.

[jweb2244]

I would definitely not do the first deal for the reasons stated above, and an additional factor is I am still not as high on Sizemore as everyone else seems to be.

I would not do the third deal either, but I could see you doing it if you think Konerko will continue to have a bounce back year.

As for the third deal, I think it is somewhat of a wash in that I don't know how much you will get from Vlad (even after his injury) and think Haren is still slightly better than Bills.

Can you help with mine (I don't know how to leave a link but it is a post earlier today involving a trade with Lowe/Konerko/Cameron)? Thanks.

[kaiser]

Big NO on trade #1.

I think I would do trade #2. Taking a risk on Vlad coming back healthy, but if it pays off, it pays off big.

Thanks for your help.

[theinflatinator91]

You definatly reject the first one. The second one is close. Bills and Haren could go either way. Vlad is getting old and is on the dl now for about a month. If you have faith in Vlad and think he can bounce back then take the deal if not then reject it aswell.

help? - viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379797&p=3041119#p3041119

[Da Rook]

Agree with some of those above me:

I would pass on deal one, because you're giving up too much. I'm not a fan of Lee and think that could hurt as the year goes on.

However, I like deal too. Vlad is banged up and out a while.

Please help me:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=379801